Abortion

What I was thinking...
Re: PBA ruling -- Sean Colgan Post Reply Top of the thread Forum
Posted by: crossbowman
04/20/2007, 16:36:57

Author Profile (About author)

Edit
...was that the SC has just embarrassed itself for the history books by dumping the woman's health exception. I don't expect this decision - or others in a similar vein by this court - to survive beyond this court. Rather, I expect this court to go down in history alongside the court that delivered the infamous decision in Plessy v. Ferguson, as an example of what a court should NOT be.

The crux of the debate in the abortion controversy is the status of the fetus, not the techniques used. Even if we assume that the fetus can be considered a living person at the gestational age at which this procedure is being used for that patient, medicine has established procedures for dealing with situations in which the welfare of two (or more) living beings is in conflict. Such conflicts, while rare, do occur in the case of certain types of conjoined twins and of certain complications involving multiple fetus pregnancies, for example. Medicine has been granted the power to make such life-and-death decisions, and it has the guidelines and experience to make such decisions, and there are well known and well-established consequences when physicians move outside those guidelines to the detriment of one of the involved patients.

It's one thing for government to regulate when the issue does not revolve around health and survival. It's quite another when government decides in a life-and-death matter that it knows better than a trained and experienced physician or better than a body of physicians looking objectively at the medical data. From where I sit, the SC by making this decision has very loudly proclaimed its intention to place its own religious bias ahead of science and health, and that's not the kind of decision that's likely to endure.

We all live in a Jello submarine,

Jello submarine, Jello sub-AAAAAAAGGHH
gurkhghgmmphmpblupblup


Post Reply | Email Friend | Alert Where am i? Original Post Top of the thread Previous | Next | Current page
Followups

Abortion