Politics and World Government

That's me. Eloquent, but obscure.
Re: Re: Are we feeding on each other now? -- Angus Cunningham Post Reply Top of the thread Forum
Posted by: crossbowman
07/31/2008, 01:02:56

Author Profile (About author)

Edit
DW brings in the idea of survival of the fittest, comparing debate to the food chain and suggesting that restricting verbal bullying is akin to creating circumstances that allow the herbivores to eat the carnivores and wear the "skins of lions".

Borrowing on that, I point out that the most aggressive individual is not necessarily the fittest, especially if he brings calamity on his fellows. Thus, the bullying debater who manages by his bullying to persuade his opponents to do the opposite of what he wants is compared to the predator who - roaring at the wrong moment - prompts a herd of herbivores into a stampede that tramples his packmates to death. That was pretty but somewhat less than clear. I apologize.

Consideration is indeed a factor in cultural evolution. We are a social species. We talk passionately about our intelligence, but our accomplishments are as firmly grounded in our propensity for cooperative behavior. Those cultures that thrive and survive are those that are most effective at ensuring the cooperative interaction of their members. Force and bullying have been used to accomplish that, but not with the same level of efficiency as more positive methods - bullied people just don't work as hard as those who feel their efforts are getting them something. Cash is always good, but respect and status seem to be equally effective.

"Robbins’s claim fails because the Hobbs Act does not apply when the National Government is the intended beneficiary of the allegedly extortionate acts."

WILKIE ET AL. v. ROBBINS. David H. Souter, Justice, U.S. Supreme Court
with John Roberts, Antonin Scalia, Anthony Kennedy,
Clarence Thomas, Stephen Breyer, and Samuel Alito concurring.


Post Reply | Email Friend | Alert Where am i? Original Post Top of the thread Previous | Next | Current page

Politics and World Government